Soutdold Fish Market in Soutdold

Incredibly fresh seafood cooked to order. The market is also wonderful. This is an order at the counter and grab a seat kind of place. There is also a licensed bar on-site. Not surprisingly this place is super popular with locals and tourists alike and the dining area gets busy fast. Long live the Southold Fish Market!

Excellent place to get some 100% fresh seafood. I always hit this spot when I come for the raw bar.

Enjoyed takeout crab-corn chowder, shrimp cocktail, grilled fish tacos, Little Neck steamers, and assorted fish platter (Charlie's) on laidback outdoor picnic tables while enjoying a breezy late afternoon. Nice extensive menu.. Everything was delicious & fresh. Apparently you can order ahead, which I strongly recommend since it got very busy with long waits & grumpy customers trying to social distance while on line. We will definitely return next time we're in the North Fork!

Fresh seafood, wide variety of fare for take out to cook at home and a good menu for eat in/at the new variety of picnic tables outside. View is cool. Excellent place to relax and enjoy a bite with friends and family. Friendly, fast service. Decent beer selection too.

Some of the best food on the North Fork. Amazing fresh fish and a menu of favorites done right. Indoor and outdoor seating. Friendly staff. It is a great place to grab some lunch with indoor & outdoor seating. They have beer on tap and you can grab some fish to take home for dinner if you get skunked out on the water. I highly recommend!

A place to visit for all seafood lovers simply the best

A classic, always a nice selection of seafood, fast and friendly service. Lots of tasty, prepared food too. Frozen and ready to serve options to take home and serve as well. Worth making part of every week's shopping and any North Fork visit for at least a lunch!

Relaxing and unpretentious, with some of the best seafood on Long Island. The selection is incredible. If you're looking for incredible food, you need to come here.

Amazing seafood and fresh. Very clean place and wonderful staff. A must stop. Great prices as well

We love this place: first of all they're very professional and very kind to help.Everything that they have is fresh the don't play with that: we love the setup , you can stop and enjoy yourself in the environment ,and take some of these fresh seafood home, thank you so much please keep it like that for a long time and differently it's gonna be a big success for the owners.

Ready for this review from a critical critic? Perfect on every level! Excellent, friendly service. Outstanding food. Fresh. Plenty of dining area. I just found a new favorite place! ⭐️ 💣 💫

I’ve spent about 10 years on and off in Greenport and the 1 thing that has always consistent.... that’s the seafood. I live in Jersey know and I have no problem riding out there for all of my favorite seafoods from some of my favorite spots a Southold Fish market is a new favorite. The last time I was there I met some people from the city that love driving an hour 1/2 for some fresh seafood, some caught the same day. Keep up the good work.

Been coming here for a few years. It's both a fish market and seafood restaurant. Service is always efficient and friendly. Really fresh seafood. A little pricey but quality is top notch. Currently they have 2 entrances. Back entrance for market. Separate side entrance for restaurant to go orders to eat all fresco at their outdoor tables or in the comfort of your own home.

Solid menu in a fair price. Great seafood quality and a very filling lobster roll. We went on a busy Saturday evening and the restaurant runs smooth and fast. Highly recommend if you are looking for a simple and local experience

Seafood joint with dog friendly outdoor seating. The food is fresh and generally reasonable, a lobster roll runs $25 and a shrimp entree is about $15.You can also grab fresh fish to cook at home. One oddity, no tip on a credit card. Cash tip only despite taking credit cards.